Despite an increase in retrenchments through 2020, after taking into account the increase in workforce size over the years, the incidence of retrenchment remained lower than all the past recessionary years.

Singapore saw a decline in retrenchments in Q4 2020, the first decline to be recorded in five quarters. In particular, there were 5,640 retrenchments made in Q4, about 4,000 less than what was recorded in Q3 (9,120).

According to the Ministry of Manpower (MOM)'s Labour Market Report Fourth Quarter 2020released by the Manpower Research and Statistics Department on Tuesday (16 March 2021), fewer retrenchments were recorded in most industries, except in air transport & supporting services, which was still affected by global travel restrictions.

Among reasons cited for the retrenchments, the report noted two that emerged top - recession/downturn in the industry, which accounted for 49% of all retrenchments; and re-organisation/restructuring, which accounted for 39%. 

On average for the year, these numbers stood at 58.6% and 36.1% respectively.

Other reasons cited for retrenchments in the year include:

  • Poor business/business failure not due to recession: 22.1%
  • High costs: 15.2%
  • Discontinued product line: 3.1%
  • Early completion of project: 1.5%

Overall retrenchment figures for the year

A year-on-year comparison with 2019 figures

On a year-on-year basis, 2020 recorded more than double the number of retrenchments in 2019 (26,110 vs 10690), due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the economy. 

More companies also carried out retrenchments in 2020 (1,962) compared to 2019 (1,189).

priya mar 2021 mom labour report q4 2020 retrenchment y o y msrd

Apart from the above, the report added that the number of retrenchments recorded last year was higher than in the Global Financial Crisis in 2009 (23,430), but lower than the Dot-Com Bust in 2001 (27,570) and Asian Financial Crisis in 1998 (32,800).

However, after taking into account the increase in workforce size over the years, the incidence of retrenchment (which measures the vulnerability of workers to retrenchment) was lower than all the past recessionary years.

 priya mar 2021 mom labour report q4 2020 retrenchment comparisons msrd

Retrenchment by residential status

Breaking the data down by residential status - 14,380 residents were retrenched in 2020, up from 6,790 in 2019. At the same time, 11,730 non-residents were retrenched last year, an increase from 3,890 in 2019.

While the above was so, non-residents were more prone to retrenchment (15.7 retrenched per 1,000 non-resident employees) than residents (11.1) in 2020, similar to previous recessions. In particular, resident workers in air transport and arts, entertainment & recreation were harder hit by COVID-19 measures.

priya mar 2021 mom labour report q4 2020 retrenchment residential status msrd

 Retrenchment by age

According to the report, in 2020, older residents in their 50s (15 retrenched per 1,000 employees) were most prone to retrenchment, as compared to other age groups.

While all age groups saw a "broad-based increase" in the incidence of retrenchment over the year, older residents aged 50 and above, as well as younger ones aged below 30, saw the largest increase (7.3 in 2020, vs 1.6 in 2019). In particular, younger residents aged below 30 observed a higher increase in the share of residents retrenched, as "disproportionately more" were in clerical, sales & service roles, which were more commonly found in industries affected by COVID-19 measures.

priya mar 2021 mom labour report q4 2020 retrenchment age group msrd

Retrenchment by gender

In terms of gender, the report revealed that women residents were more prone to retrenchments last year (11.3 retrenched per 1,000 employees), as compared to their male counterparts (10.9 retrenched per 1,000 employees), unlike the preceding years.

This, the report noted, was due to an increase in women residents being retrenched (from 45% to 50%) over the year, mainly in arts, entertainment & recreation and retail trade, industries which were more affected by COVID-19 measures and where women were over-represented. 

priya mar 2021 mom labour report q4 2020 retrenchment gendermsrd

Further highlights of the report: Employment and unemployment figures

Employment

According to the data, the contraction in total employment moderated in Q4 2020 (-7,9001). Resident employment rose for the second consecutive quarter to 34,500, while non-resident employment continued to decline (-42,400).

Further, the Employment Diffusion Index (EDI) for residents held steady over the quarter at 64.3 in the quarter, indicating that increases in resident employment was "broad-based across industries". On the other hand, it remained "markedly below" the mid-point of 50 for non-residents (16.3), indicating that most industries experienced a decline in non-resident employment.

Unemployment

In December 2020, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rates (overall: 3.3%; resident: 4.4%; citizen: 4.5%) continued to moderate month-on-month from November:

  • December 2020: 3.3% overall, 4.4% among residents, and 4.5% among citizens.
  • November 2020: 3.4% overall, 4.6% among residents, and 4.7% among citizens.

The resident unemployment rate recorded in this period was also lower than in September 2020 (4.8%), and this decline was broad-based across most age and education groups.

Lastly, in January 2021, unemployment rates continued to decline slightly at the overall level (3.2%) and for residents (4.3%). It remained unchanged for citizens (4.5%).


Commenting on the highlights in a Facebook post, Manpower Minister Josephine Teo noted despite a "broad improvement" in the labour market in Q4 2020, "we cannot underestimate the risks that lie in the months ahead."

"We are not yet opening our borders fully, and for an externally-connected economy like ours, this will continue to weigh on our economy, especially in the aviation and hospitality sectors. With changes to industries brought about by COVID-19, jobs-skills mismatches will also continue to be an issue that we will need to tackle.

"Looking ahead, our priority must be to ensure that employers and every segment of the workforce emerge stronger from this pandemic. We will continue our efforts to help workers upskill, find their career progression path and match them to good jobs though government programmes such as the #SGUnited Jobs and Skills Package. For employers, we will support them in their business transformation efforts."

Similarly, in a separate Facebook post, NTUC Assistant Secretary-General, Patrick Tay pointed out that moving ahead, Tier 1 companies will "continue to be facing downside and retrenchment risks with slow and incremental opening of travel arrangements between countries as well as gradual curtailment of government subvention through the JSS."

He also highlighted that reskilling and second skilling "will be an imperative" to ensure workers stay employed and employable.

"Employers need to support and be alongside workers/unions in this continuous education/lifelong learning journey."


Lead image and Infographics / MOM's Manpower Statistics and Research Department

Human Resources Online is on Telegram! Follow us @humanresourcesonline or click here for all the latest weekly HR and manpower news from around the region